Hi Madmin, though I like it the way that it is, where you don't know who actually gave you the great analysis, takes away a bit of the "buddy" system mentality from it in my view.
I have also recieved some "great analysis" points (may surprise some,lol) for posts that nobody "liked", so perhaps some also like the anonymity of the function, perhaps they may not have acknowledged the post if they knew I was going to be alerted on who it was from.
Though as usual I am probably in the minority but may be worth discussing it amongst whatever group analysis these things.